Girl, 17, shoots new father to death after he delivered a pizza to her home, court documents reveal

0
15

A 17-year-old girl shot a Domino’s delivery driver dead after luring the new father to an abandoned house with a fake pizza order, according to court documents. 

Jaelynn Billups and her boyfriend Alberto Vanmeter tried to rob Joshua Ungersma, 37, while he was delivering the pizza in Lafayette, Indiana, witnesses alleged.

Mr Ungersma is believed to have shot Vanmeter in self-defense after the 19-year-old tried to rob him.

The delivery driver then reportedly went across the street and asked someone to call the police, after which Billups allegedly shot him at point blank range.

Police found Mr Ungersma dead on North 16th Street on August 31 after there were reports of ‘shots fired’ at around 11.15pm.

They also found the body of Billups’s boyfriend Vanmeter nearby with a Domino’s pizza box, two drinks and cash laying on the ground beside him.

New father Joshua Ungersma, 37, was shot to his death while he delivered a pizza to an abandoned home in Lafayette, Indiana

Witness Patrick Gibson claims Mr Ungesma was uninjured after the first shots were heard and told him Vanmeter had tried to rob him, reported the Lafayette Journal & Courier.

Mr Gibson said Billups then came from across the street and shot Mr Ungesma dead. 

Another witness also alleged Mr Ungesma had asked someone to call police before Billups shot him.

Police said Billups was standing over one of the victims when they arrived and she had phoned the cops with the same phone she ordered the pizza on, reported WISHTV.

Police said Domino’s Pizza delivery driver Mr Ungersma was found with ‘a .38 S&W revolver in his pocket with the rounds fired’. He had a permit to carry the weapon.

Jaelynn Billups, 17, was charged with killing Joshua Ungersma causing Ungersma to kill Alberto Vanmeter, 19

Jaelynn Billups, 17, was charged with killing Joshua Ungersma causing Ungersma to kill Alberto Vanmeter, 19

When police ordered Billups to show her hands, she threw a 9mm handgun onto the sidewalk and was detained, reported WTHR.

A coroner determined Mr Ungersma died of multiple gunshot wounds while Vanmeter died of a single gunshot wound. 

Jaelynn Billups, 17, was charged in Tippecanoe Superior Court 2 with killing Joshua Ungersma and is being held without bond.

In a second murder count, she was also charged with causing Mr Ungersma to kill Alberto Vanmeter, 19. 

She was also charged with conspiracy to commit armed robbery, armed robbery, theft, pointing a firearm, and carrying a handgun without a license. 

Billups told the judge during an initial hearing September 8 that her family was planning on hiring an attorney. Her trial date was set for February 23, 2021.

Mr Ungersma worked a second job at a Domino’s store on Greenbush Street in Lafayette, which is donating 75 per cent of sales through Friday to his family. 

The owners hope to raise around $15,000 for the Ungersma family to support his newborn baby.

Domino’s store owner Jimmy Ruedlinger said: ‘We want to be able to do whatever we can for the family.

‘They’re going through a lot right now, obviously, with the loss of their father, the husband, a son in the mom’s case. 

Mr Ungersma worked a second job at a Domino's store on Greenbush Street in Lafayette, which is donating 75 per cent of sales through Friday to his family

Mr Ungersma worked a second job at a Domino’s store on Greenbush Street in Lafayette, which is donating 75 per cent of sales through Friday to his family

‘We’re a family here, and we’re a team, and we’re going to take care of whatever we can take care of at this point.’

Mr Ungersma leaves behind his wife Jenny, stepson Logan Hindsley, and his six-month-old son Sebastian.

He had also worked as a butcher at Payless Supermarket for the past 13 years and joined the Domino’s staff two years ago for extra cash to support his young family. 

Friend Jamie Wilkins who organised a fundraised for his funeral said: ‘The memorial services have been both heartbreaking and healing. 

‘It was so wonderful to hear everyone’s memories of Josh through this fundraiser and at the service. 

‘Josh’s life definitely made such a great impact on so many lives. They say the good die young… it hits so close to home. 

‘Josh has now been laid to rest and will forever watch over those he loves.’